"If it's provable we can kill it."
Or, excuse me? Thought has color now?
Published on August 16, 2006 By EmperorofIceCream In US Domestic
The title of this article is actually a quote. You can find it on page 8 of The Richmond Voice (issue for August 9 - 15 2006), the local rag that caters exclusively to the Black population of Richmond. This... What exactly shall we call it? This attempt to overturn 5000 years of philosophy? This grotesquely, abominably, racist statement? This attempt to introduce America's greatest curse - the unrelieved self-pity, the perpetual victimhood, the unending resentment, of the American Black (god forbid that I should contravene the racial paranoia of JU and refer to them as what they actually are, American N******) into that field of human thought that extends in an unbroken arc from Socrates to the present day?

A Black mind?

I read The Richmond Voice for a variety of reasons. It passes the time while I wait for the laundry to go through its various cycles (it's given away free at the laundromat we use; free, because no Black would waste any part of his Welfare check on buying it - what? forego buying his fawty ounces in favor of a newspaper?); it provides an insight into the concerns of the more articulate members of the Black community, an insight that isn't to be had otherwise; and because, very occasionally, I find myself in agreement with some of its editorial and op-ed pieces, especially those concerning the effectiveness - or otherwise - of the city government.

Today was laundry day. So, having loaded the machines and set them going I sat myself down with a copy of the paper and began to read. Nothing of any great moment transpired until I came to page 8 which bears the headline 'Black episcopalians urged to focus on hard issues'.

Black Episcopalians? I was under the impression that Episcopalians are some variety of Christian - among whom, I was once led to believe, there is neither male nor female, nor even Greek or Jew:

Gal 3:28 There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus.

Apparently I was wrong. Not only are there Black Episcopalians, there are Black Episcopalians in possession of something referred to (by one Reverend Canon Nelson Pinder) as Black minds. Black minds... I doubt very much that those reading this will understand the sense of horror this grotesque, detestable statment induced in me; because, to date, I've yet to find anyone else who writes here who has an appreciation for the historical development of philosophy in the West, nor for the titanic struggles that have raged over that tradition for the past 5000 years, struggles that have involved the spilling not merely of ink but of blood.

The integrity (and the supreme, transcendent, value that has been attributed to that integrity) of the human creature is the core value, the fundamental basis, of the entire tradition of the philosophy of the West. Socrates died for it. The French waged the bloodiest and most destructive conflict of their national life over it. Thomas Acquinas, the greatest and most potent thinker ever produced by Christendom, labored his entire life to validate it. Luther sanctioned the slaughter of countless thousands of European peasants in order, precisely, to secure it. Immanuel Kant, the greatest and most subtle philosopher of the Modern epoch, suffered the torments of Hell in the process of reconciling that value with the necessary existence of the State - and in the process of doing so gave birth to that fantastical creature which is the bedrock of American culture - the individual.

And this... reverend... individual annihilates this tradition, and with it its unimaginable cost in human struggle and suffering, with a single and utterly glib phrase. A Black mind is a terrible thing to waste. There is no such thing as a Black mind. If it were possible for such a philosophical abomination to exist then the entire history of struggle and suffering involved in establishing the integrity of the human creature as one, and only one, type of entity has been an utter and complete waste of effort and blood - and we may as well surrender to the Islamist tyrants and their Caliphate right now, because without the undergirding support of the Graeco-Christian tradition of philosophy we are left with no answer to, no alternative to, the philosophical foundations of Islam. Dear God, just how stupid are you ignorant motherfuckers anyway?

Not only is this true, but the entire struggle of American slaves for their freedom and independence is utterly invalidated. If humanity is not of one mind, if the fundamental principle of the integrity of the human creature as one, and only one, type of being is to be invalidated in this way, then there is no counter-argument to Aristotle's statement that the slave is nothing more than a living tool - and that the fitness of human creatures to own such living tools is demonstrated through war and conquest. Those who conquer are human; those who are conquered are fitted, by nature, to be slaves. The exact same type of conquest that American Blacks claim to have been subjected to and to have suffered from since the first slaves were brought from Africa and the Caribbean to the USA.

With one blindly ignorant statement, this reverend fool has justified, in the face of a congregation as ignorant as he himself is, the very basis of the slavery that Blacks in America continue to protest is the basis of their social inequality. If there is such a thing as a Black mind, which there is not, then the basis of slavery is justified and every Black in America ought at once to acknowledge the superiority of the White race - because it was Whites who made of them 'living tools' - and they could not have done so unless they were possessed of a 'White mind' of infinitely greater superiority to the 'Black mind' of the slave class.

Black Episcopalians, possessed of Black minds... The ignorance of Americans, of both skin colors, continues to astound and horrify me. But I suppose it's only just: the folly of the fool is it's own punishment. And truly, when it comes to such things, America is a nation of fools.

Comments
on Aug 16, 2006
. appearance dot
on Aug 16, 2006

Just the fact the blacks keep adding fuel to the fire with statements like that, it just BLACKENS the whole civil rights act!

I have said it before and will say it again, try to have a WHITE MISS America pageant, or a congressional WHITE Caucus,Or a WHITE history month and see what happens.

on Aug 16, 2006
We used to have all white events, they just didn't have to call it that in the title. It was ASSUMED that it was a white event, because what else would it be? That's how awful it was. Because of that, white events are now for everyone, but there are still separate events for minorities... because they have no chance in white events? That's the only logical explanation. It's stupid. Like calling their mind a black mind. Why are you separating yourselves? I thought you wanted in! Racial issues just confuse me.
on Aug 17, 2006
pinder merely coopted & bastardized a promotional slogan orginated by the advertising council on behalf of the united negro college fund in the mid-70s: a mind is a terrible thing to waste.

on the offchance you're unfamiliar with it, here's one of the graphics:



and here's a fairly astute commentary on the campaign itself lifted from "A Mind is a Terrible Thing to Waste: A Retrospective of the Advertising Campaign for the United Negro College Fund" by jason chambers ph.d Link

When the Advertising Council took over the advertising for the UNCF the nation was mired in crisis due to the economy, war in Vietnam, and with minority groups still battling to secure their rights. Consequently, if improperly handled, the advertising campaign for the UNCF could have presented blacks as charity cases, or it could have been viewed as patronizing to the black community. Instead, the creators of the advertisements focused on the potential inherent in the African American community, potential that had been denied due to discrimination and prejudice. But rather than feeling sorry for blacks, the advertisements encouraged Americans to help them help themselves and a campaign and a slogan were born. In the process the campaign has helped not only at the practical level of financial contributions, but it has also helped many Americans change their beliefs about black achievement and potential.

my problem with pinder's version is much simpler than yours. idiotic tho it may be, it's not nearly as outrageous, entertaining nor revealing as that pronounced by former vice-president and whitehouse moron emeritus, dan quayle, at a (where else???) united negro college fund fund raiser:

"What a waste it is to lose one's mind. Or not to have a mind is being very wasteful. How true that is."

perhaps the only time in his life to that moment quayle spoke from experience.
on Aug 17, 2006
To: Moderateman

I agree with you entirely. One of the very first things to impress itself upon me, after my arrival in America, was the peculiriarity of the notion of 'Afro-American' or 'Amerindian-American' or any other phrase that attempted to denote a status that was at once inclusive of American citizenship and at the same time separatist in nature.

Until every American citizen identifies himself as an American first, and a member of an ethnicity second, we will be prey to the fundamental aggresion and stupidity of all those who cannot see that to be American is the greatest blessing that one can possess in this world.
on Aug 17, 2006
'Amerindian-American'


previously referred to as 'american indians'. see, ya just gotta turn it around 180 degrees.

Until every American citizen identifies himself as an American first, and a member of an ethnicity second, we will be prey to the fundamental aggresion and stupidity of all those who cannot see that to be American is the greatest blessing that one can possess in this world.


that's pretty much why the great white father decided he hadda transport children of the southwest nations to florida and north dakota, cut their hair short, make em wear hard sole shoes and speak only english.

only i believe that whole thing demonstrated--rather than minimized--the aggressive stupidity involved in forcing people to feel blessed.
on Aug 17, 2006
To: kingbee

I cannot deny that you are one of the most lucid, perceptive, and eloquent commentators on JU. I cannot deny that you are one of the very few here on JU that present me with arguments that I respect, couched in forms that are often as amusing as they are challenging.

Neither can I deny that, occasionally, you entirely and completely miss the point - as you have done in your present response.

I'm aware of the campaign to raise funds for the colleges dedicated to negroes: how could I not be, since their wretched banner ads are everywhere across the net? Which means that I'm equally well aware of the origin of the phrase 'A mind is a terrible thing to waste' - a slogan with which I am in agreement. It is a terrible thing, to deny to the mind of an individual, of whatever color, the opportunity for development and advancement. Having attended college myself, having benefited from that experience, how could I deny to others, of whatever color, the benefits I myself have received, without being a hypocrite of the first water?

I encourage every Black in America to attend college. It will free them from their poverty, and from the chains of their resentment (unless, of course, they are taught by American 'liberals').

But none of this has anything to do with the point I made and which, in your response, you entirely missed. What is at stake in the comment of the reverend fool against whom I animadverted is the integrity of the human species as human; as one entity to whom rights, and obligations, accrue.

One entity, capable of being subject to law, which is the highest achievement of human culture; one being, capable of experiencing, and expressing, the civil partnership which is the child of law and therefore the greatest achievement of human cooperation and collaberation. All these things are utterly destroyed in the phrase 'A Black mind'. This is an annihilation of the most significant attainments of human civilization, things which have cost us ten thousand years to acheive, things which are utterly lost if the statement of the reverend fool to whom I referred is to be believed, things which are completely glossed over in your response.

This statement, A Black mind, is an egregious assualt upon everything that constitutes our civilization. It is a matter for the most solemn and serious condemnation, not a reference to the ludicrous nonsense of an advertising campaign.

But, as I said in the original article, the folly of the fool is its own punishment. And while Americans, even intelligent and articulate Americans such as yourself, relegate such attacks upon the founding principles of their civilization to comments upon the worthiness of advertising campaigns, there can be no hope that American culture will take its rightful, pre-eminent, place in human experience.
on Aug 17, 2006
To: kingbee

that's pretty much why the great white father decided he hadda transport children of the southwest nations to florida and north dakota, cut their hair short, make em wear hard sole shoes and speak only english.


There is nothing cynical in my belief that American culture, its hegemony, is the destiny of Mankind. If countless thousands of other races and cultures must be destroyed in order to achieve that aim, then so be it. Let them die. If they resist us, they are not fit to live.

Let them die, or acquiesce. Be damned to them.
on Aug 17, 2006
To: Jythier

As with Moderateman, I could not agree more with this statement:

Why are you separating yourselves? I thought you wanted in!


They don't. Blacks in America want to be seperate and unequal - the inequalities involved operating in their favor. No Black will admit it, but what they truly want is revenge. I can understand this and appreciate it - if I were in their position and had their history, I would want revenge too.

But the fact of the matter is that they will never get what they want: economics, the socio-political system, jurisprudence: all these things stand in their way and always will. Their only hope is to do what they are presently doing - which is to make Black the new 'cool'. In that they are succeeding, slowly, mainly because the guilt-ridden White 'liberal' media is engaged in collaborating with them.

Despite the thrust of this article, despite my sincere advocacy of the overarching impetus of Western philosophy, I remain convinced that, at least in relation to the Black population of America, Aristotle's assertion that some races are natural slaves is true. The American Black has earned his servitude, and continues to demonstrate that it is justly deserved.

That doesn't, of course, prevent him from becoming the principal exponent of the chief values of contemporary America. As I said, the folly of the fool is its own punishment - and there is no greater fool in the America of today than the White man.